Wednesday, August 26, 2015

Week 1 Storytelling: Jack and Jill



“Jack and Jill went up the hill

To fetch a pail of water;

Jack fell down and broke his crown,

And Jill came tumbling after.”


The Nursery Rhyme Book, edited by Andrew Lang and illustrated by L. Leslie Brooke (1897). Web source: Project Gutenberg.


Jack and Jill had been neighbors since they were born. Their parents were the best of friends, yet the two had never really been that close.

Jack was seventeen. He was known as a very hard-working young man. He was always focused on his work and deeds for others. He was most famous for being the town handyman. If anything broke, he was there to fix it. He was never afraid to get his hands dirty. In fact, some would say he actually enjoyed it. Jack was very outgoing and always up for a challenge. It seemed he was a lady’s man too. Jack was the typical hard-working and handsome man every woman dreams of.

With Jack focusing so much on his work, he never had time to pay attention to the lovely young lady next door, Jill.

Jill was also seventeen. She was very shy and not very outgoing. She seemed to lack self-confidence, which was the main factor in keeping her from Jack. Jill had been watching Jack from afar for many years. In fact, they had every class together since they were four years old. Even though her parents were best friends with Jack’s parents, she just never found the guts to strike up a conversation with him. She know how devoted he was to his work and how much he enjoyed helping others when he was needed, so the last thing she wanted was to distract him or interrupt his lifestyle.

One day, an older woman in the town told Jack to climb the tallest hill in the town to fetch a bucket of the cleanest and purest water for her. Jill saw this as her chance to talk to Jack. She thought she could offer him a helping hand.

“Jack, I heard you have to go all the way to the top of the tallest hill,” said Jill, with a shaky voice.

“Yes, I do. It will not be hard to get up the hill, but traveling back down with the full bucket of water will be difficult,” said Jack.

“Well, I bet it would be easier if you had an extra set of hands to help you carry that full bucket all the way back down,” said Jill.

“I think you are right. Would you like to help me?” asked Jack.

“I would love to! I mean, I think I could help you, yeah, I can try,” said Jill.

The next day, Jack and Jill ventured up the hill to fetch a pail of water. They made it to the top with no problems at all. After they filled the pail and started to head down the hill, Jack lost his balance and went tumbling down. His fall startled Jill, which caused her to go tumbling down the hill as well.

After dusting themselves off at the bottom of the hill, they realized they had lost their pail full of water. As disappointed as they were for losing the water, they laughed it off and continued their day together. From that day forward, Jack and Jill worked together to help the town they grew up in and lived happily ever after.

The End.

Jack and Jill by Sue Clark.Wikimedia Commons



Author's Note:
This nursery rhyme is about two people, Jack and Jill, who go up a hill to get some water and then fall down the hill. Like most nursery rhymes, it is very self-explanatory. However, while being self-explanatory overall, it is also very vague when it comes to the characters in the story.

I enjoyed writing for this one because it has very little detail so I was able to use a lot of imagination. I have always been a fan of love stories and such, so my imagination of course wanted to write something cute and love-related. Most people assume Jack and Jill are brother and sister, or something along those lines. I thought shaking it up and making them potential lovers would be more interesting. It is rare in nursery rhymes and riddles that we get any background on the characters, so being able to make that part up and use my imagination to create these characters from scratch is very fun.

After doing a little bit of outside research on this nursery rhyme, I found out that “Jack and Jill” could possibly have a romantic connotation to it already! A proverb says “A good Jack makes a good Jill.” Reading this made me happy, but at the same time, I felt like it took away from my creativity.

12 comments:

  1. I really liked how you took such a well-known Nursery Rhyme and made it your own. It's never easy to take something so well known and put a unique twist on it. I liked how you took the two characters and gave them both a back story that fleshed them out and made them more believable. I look forward to your other posts.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I'm glad you turned this nursery rhyme into a love story. Every time I think of Jack and Jill I think of the sinks that are side by side each other in a master bathroom, so it would make sense that they were lovers. Everyone always thinks I'm crazy and that they were brother and sister. However, I really enjoyed your version.

    ReplyDelete
  3. First off, thanks for all the compliments on my writing! So sweet. This story was sweet as well. Like Jack and Jill riiight. Like Bonnie and Clyde. Like Mickey and Minnie. Like 50 Shades of Grey. Like Kennedy and Marilyn. Nah but your story is great as it is your own and a spin on a true classic we all know. Your story structure is A1. Your grammar impeccable. You're a true author. Stay dope.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hey Molly! I do love a happy ending. I really liked your take on the Jack and Jill story. I had never thought of Jack and Jill being a romantic story. In the fourth paragraph "know" should be changed to "knew." Dialogue is tricky and can be done a couple of different ways. Jill's dialogue near the end needs a little work. You could try, "I mean...I think I could help you. Yeah — I can try" or another combination if you wanted. I get what you were trying to do with the commas, but changing it will make it look cleaner and get your point across better. I think it would also improve your story if you describe what Jack and Jill looked like. I know you said Jack was handsome, but what exactly does that look like? A sharp jaw? Blue eyes? A six pack? Overall, I enjoyed reading your story. I look forward to reading more of them!

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hi Molly. I really like how you took a very short rhyme and turned it into a very detailed story about how two people met. I like that two very different people that wouldn't have otherwise met became best friends and worked together to make their town a better place to live in. You made a classic rhyme into a modern love story. A little more detail from the point where the story ended would be nice. I would like to know if they just stayed as friends or began a relationship. Other than that I really liked your story. I couldn't find anything grammar wise to help you out. Sorry! Keep up the good writing!

    ReplyDelete
  6. Hey Molly! First impressions, I thought this story was absolutely adorable and sweet! I loved that you gave each Jack and Jill a back story, as well giving them a shared history which I thought was a really cool addition to the story and gave it a foundation to start on! The dialogue was my favorite part of your story: I loved how simple the language was, it seemed exactly what a shy seventeen year old girl would tell the boy she likes! I really liked when she stumbled over telling him she would love to help him! The introduction sentence grabs my attention and draws me in to the story and the history between Jack and Jill! The ending sentence I like because it is very simple and typical of the ending of a fairytale type love story! I think your image could be really cool right after the paragraph about them falling since it shows them falling down the hill!

    ReplyDelete
  7. I really enjoyed how you gave Jack and Jill a back story! You did a great job and it was very creative. I always assumed that they were siblings, but creating a story where they were each other's love interesting was a new spin for me. Even though, as you mentioned in your Author's note, it seems that they were always supposed to be associated with romance rather than family. Good job on the finding out more about the other interpretations of Jack and Jill

    ReplyDelete
  8. Hi Molly!
    What a great way to tell the story of Jack and Jill. I too have always wondered what they were doing up there, and how they knew each other! Thanks for filling us in! I think it may be helpful for the reader to tell us what they look like. I have a vision of them in my head most likely from a book written a hundred years ago. They are little blond kids with chubby red cheeks. I like the story overall,I do not see any major issues. I agree with Ann-Marie about the placement of the image. It would be helpful there, or at the top to give the reader something to focus on as they read, like the little blip of the original story at the top. I think this is a fun story and I enjoyed reading what you have done with it!

    ReplyDelete
  9. I liked how you took a 4 line nursery rhyme and made it into a complete story about it. It was also nice that you included the nursery rhyme first because it gave sense of what I was to expect. I liked the dialogue between Jack and Jill. It adds a sense of depth between the characters and how they end up liking each other. It was also neat that you added a little background story with each character. It shows creativity to be able to create something from an existing nursery rhyme. It feels like a plot of a love movie.

    I didn’t see grammatical errors or parts that felt confusing, which is good. The story was clear and flowed nicely between paragraphs. This showed a mark of a good writer. I didn’t read any comments, so I didn’t know if there some changes requested by the readers so I don’t know what you started with. I liked this story regardless and liked the creative way you went with it.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Hey Molly, It was very interesting to see how your integrated your creativity with this nursery rhyme. I really like what you did just as you explained, that instead of siblings the two be lovers. It gives very good plot twist to what most people think of Jack and Jill and read this fable. I like how you made Jack the hard working boy while Jill was the little nervous girl with the crush. It gives the story a romantic feel of how the girl wants the boy but she is to shy to show it. It is a very classical feel to a love story. The happy ending to the story was very nice as well. I like how you didn’t go into much detail if they ever became more then friends so it lets us wonder and imagine. You did a very good job! Keep up the good work

    ReplyDelete
  11. Hi Molly! I think your created a very cute version of Jack and Jill. It doesn’t take away from your creativity at all that some other author hinted at a romantic connection. Great minds think alike.

    I like how you developed a backstory between Jack and Jill. They have very similar backgrounds but are polar opposites. I think you could add some memories into the story to give it even more depth.

    At one point you say that Jack is a lady’s man but in the next line you say that he is too busy to pay attention to Jill. That confused me a little bit. A “lady’s man” is a notorious flirt. Not a hard-working, selfless hunk like Jack. ;)

    I’m glad Jack didn’t actually “break his crown,” in your version. Emergency rooms aren’t very romantic. I can easily see two teenagers bonding over laughter after falling down a hill.

    You might consider is combining some of your sentences to add structural variety. I think that some of the sentences have very similar meanings and you could say the same thing with fewer words.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Hey I like it!

    One thing I would add, is what time period this is in. It just helps the reader picture what is happening more.

    Also, if you're going to keep the love story description in your blurb I might have the story boil down to one moment where Jack and Jill kiss, or agree to go out, or one saves the other.

    If the story stayed as is, I would just change the blurb to a guy and girl ending up together from interesting circumstances.

    I like the story! Maybe add some awkward circumstances between Jack and Jill so when they do end up together it makes it that much sweeter. Ya know since they both royally would of messed up with each with neither being great when around the opposite sex.

    Oh I just thought of this! What if when they fall, Jack falls on top of Jill? That is hilarious and captivating.

    These are just suggestions! You don't have to add these!

    ReplyDelete